SelectionSquareSteals & Busts

Biggest Buffalo Bills busts

Picks that fell furthest short of what their draft slot usually produces. Players still playing aren't counted. How this works

StealsBusts
Biggest steals everWorst #1 picksBuffalo Bills drafts →
  1. 1Aaron MaybinDE · #11 in 2009 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 5 vs 58 expected at #11−53
  2. 2Perry TuttleWR · #19 in 1982 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 2 vs 47 expected at #19−45
  3. 3Mike WilliamsT · #4 in 2002 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 26 vs 68 expected at #4−42
  4. 4Tony HunterTE · #12 in 1983 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 15 vs 56 expected at #12−41
  5. 5EJ ManuelQB · #16 in 2013 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 8 vs 47 expected at #16−39
  6. 6Gene BradleyQB · #37 in 1980 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 0 vs 38 expected at #37−38
  7. 7John McCargoDT · #26 in 2006 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 4 vs 42 expected at #26−38
  8. 8Kaiir ElamCB · #23 in 2022 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 4 vs 42 expected at #23−38
  9. 9Erik FlowersDE · #26 in 2000 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 6 vs 42 expected at #26−36
  10. 10Mark TraynowiczG · #29 in 1985 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 5 vs 39 expected at #29−34
  11. 11J.P. LosmanQB · #22 in 2004 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 10 vs 44 expected at #22−34
  12. 12James HardyWR · #41 in 2008 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 2 vs 34 expected at #41−32
  13. 13Torell TroupDT · #41 in 2010 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 2 vs 34 expected at #41−32
  14. 14Eric RichardsonWR · #41 in 1984 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 3 vs 34 expected at #41−31
  15. 15Shaq LawsonDE · #19 in 2016 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 16 vs 47 expected at #19−31
  16. 16Derrick BurroughsDB · #14 in 1985 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 21 vs 51 expected at #14−30
  17. 17James WilliamsDB · #16 in 1990 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 17 vs 47 expected at #16−30
  18. 18C.J. SpillerPro Bowl ×1RB · #9 in 2010 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 28 vs 58 expected at #9−30
  19. 19Cyrus KouandjioT · #44 in 2014 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 3 vs 33 expected at #44−30
  20. 20Chris WilliamsDB · #49 in 1981 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 2 vs 31 expected at #49−29
  21. 21Bucky BrooksDB · #48 in 1994 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 3 vs 31 expected at #48−28
  22. 22Matt KoflerQB · #48 in 1982 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 4 vs 31 expected at #48−27
  23. 23James PattonNT · #55 in 1992 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 1 vs 28 expected at #55−27
  24. 24Leodis McKelvinDB · #11 in 2008 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 31 vs 58 expected at #11−27
  25. 25Sammy WatkinsWR · #4 in 2014 by Buffalo BillsSSI_Val 41 vs 68 expected at #4−27