Who was still available

329 players drafted after pick #5, best career value first. Tap a player to swap him in for Jim McMahon.

• 1Mike MunchakHOFAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×9G · Penn St.Taken #8 by Houston Oilers143+82
• 2Marcus AllenHOFAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×6RB · USCTaken #10 by Los Angeles Raiders142+81
• 3Andre TippettHOFAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×5LB · IowaTaken #41 by New England Patriots121+60
• 4Luis SharpePro Bowl ×3T · UCLATaken #16 by St. Louis Cardinals96+35
• 5Steve JordanPro Bowl ×6TE · BrownTaken #179 by Minnesota Vikings92+31
• 6Jeff BryantDE · ClemsonTaken #6 by Seattle Seahawks78+17
• 7Rodney HolmanPro Bowl ×3TE · TulaneTaken #82 by Cincinnati Bengals78+17
• 8Mark DuperPro Bowl ×3WR · Northwestern St. (LA)Taken #52 by Miami Dolphins77+16
• 9Mike QuickAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×5WR · North Carolina St.Taken #20 by Philadelphia Eagles76+15
• 10Mike MerriweatherPro Bowl ×3LB · PacificTaken #70 by Pittsburgh Steelers72+11
• 11Tootie RobbinsT · East CarolinaTaken #90 by St. Louis Cardinals71+10
• 12Pete MetzelaarsTE · WabashTaken #75 by Seattle Seahawks69+8
• 13Jimmy WilliamsLB · NebraskaTaken #15 by Detroit Lions65+4
• 14Roy FosterPro Bowl ×2G · USCTaken #24 by Miami Dolphins65+4
• 15Ron HallstromG · IowaTaken #22 by Green Bay Packers62+1
• 16Mike BaabC · TexasTaken #115 by Cleveland Browns60−1
• 17Fred MarionPro Bowl ×1DB · Miami (FL)Taken #112 by New England Patriots58−3
• 18Eugene MarveLB · Saginaw Valley St.Taken #59 by Buffalo Bills56−5
• 19Morten AndersenHOFAll-Pro ×3Pro Bowl ×7K · Michigan St.Taken #86 by New Orleans Saints55−6
• 20Brad EdelmanPro Bowl ×1G · MissouriTaken #30 by New Orleans Saints53−8
• 21Sean FarrellG · Penn St.Taken #17 by Tampa Bay Buccaneers52−9
• 22Joe MorrisAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×2RB · SyracuseTaken #45 by New York Giants52−9
• 23Robert BrownDE · Virginia TechTaken #98 by Green Bay Packers51−10
• 24Sammy WinderPro Bowl ×2RB · Southern MissTaken #131 by Denver Broncos51−10
• 25Pat BeachTE · Washington St.Taken #140 by Baltimore Colts51−10
• 26Gerald RiggsPro Bowl ×3RB · Arizona St.Taken #9 by Atlanta Falcons50−11
• 27Vann McElroyPro Bowl ×2DB · BaylorTaken #64 by Los Angeles Raiders49−12
• 28Bubba ParisT · MichiganTaken #29 by San Francisco 49ers48−13
• 29Reggie McElroyT · West Texas A&MTaken #51 by New York Jets47−14
• 30Rich BaldingerG · Wake ForestTaken #270 by New York Giants46−15
• 31Darrin NelsonRB · StanfordTaken #7 by Minnesota Vikings45−16
• 32Bruce ScholtzLB · TexasTaken #33 by Seattle Seahawks45−16
• 33Bruce McNortonDB · Georgetown (KY)Taken #96 by Detroit Lions42−19
• 34Earl FerrellRB · East Tennessee St.Taken #125 by St. Louis Cardinals41−20
• 35Rob TaylorT · NorthwesternTaken #328 by Philadelphia Eagles41−20
• 36Paul LankfordDB · Penn St.Taken #80 by Miami Dolphins38−23
• 37David GallowayDT · FloridaTaken #38 by St. Louis Cardinals35−26
• 38Vernon DeanDB · San Diego St.Taken #49 by Washington Redskins35−26
• 39Stacey BaileyWR · San Jose St.Taken #63 by Atlanta Falcons34−27
• 40Mike PagelQB · Arizona St.Taken #84 by Baltimore Colts33−28
• 41Jeff DavisLB · ClemsonTaken #128 by Tampa Bay Buccaneers33−28
• 42John CannonDE · William & MaryTaken #83 by Tampa Bay Buccaneers32−29
• 43Gary AndersonAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×4K · SyracuseTaken #171 by Buffalo Bills30−31
• 44Sam ClancyDE · PittsburghTaken #284 by Seattle Seahawks30−31
• 45Terry TauschG · TexasTaken #39 by Minnesota Vikings29−32
• 46Anthony GriggsLB · Ohio St.Taken #105 by Philadelphia Eagles29−32
• 47Ken DallafiorG · MinnesotaTaken #124 by Pittsburgh Steelers29−32
• 48Walter AbercrombieRB · BaylorTaken #12 by Pittsburgh Steelers28−33
• 49Butch WoolfolkRB · MichiganTaken #18 by New York Giants28−33
• 50Tony ElliottNT · North TexasTaken #114 by New Orleans Saints28−33