Who was still available

261 players drafted after pick #1, best career value first. Tap a player to swap him in for Carson Palmer.

• 1Jason WittenAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×11TE · TennesseeTaken #69 by Dallas Cowboys167+77
• 2Troy PolamaluHOFAll-Pro ×4Pro Bowl ×8DB · USCTaken #16 by Pittsburgh Steelers150+60
• 3Kevin WilliamsAll-Pro ×5Pro Bowl ×6DT · Oklahoma St.Taken #9 by Minnesota Vikings144+54
• 4Andre JohnsonHOFAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×7WR · Miami (FL)Taken #3 by Houston Texans143+53
• 5Terrell SuggsAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×7LB · Arizona St.Taken #10 by Baltimore Ravens135+45
• 6Lance BriggsAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×7LB · ArizonaTaken #68 by Chicago Bears113+23
• 7Terence NewmanPro Bowl ×2DB · Kansas St.Taken #5 by Dallas Cowboys105+15
• 8Anquan BoldinPro Bowl ×3WR · Florida St.Taken #54 by Arizona Cardinals102+12
• 9Jordan GrossAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×3T · UtahTaken #8 by Carolina Panthers92+2
• 10Robert MathisAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×5DE · Alabama A&MTaken #138 by Indianapolis Colts92+2
• 11Charles TillmanAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×2DB · LouisianaTaken #35 by Chicago Bears88−2
• 12Rashean MathisAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×1DB · Bethune-CookmanTaken #39 by Jacksonville Jaguars85−5
• 13Asante SamuelAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×4DB · Central FloridaTaken #120 by New England Patriots85−5
• 14Nnamdi AsomughaAll-Pro ×2Pro Bowl ×3DB · CaliforniaTaken #31 by Oakland Raiders84−6
• 15David DiehlPro Bowl ×1G · IllinoisTaken #160 by New York Giants75−15
• 16Dallas ClarkAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×1TE · IowaTaken #24 by Indianapolis Colts71−19
• 17Calvin PaceDE · Wake ForestTaken #18 by Arizona Cardinals69−21
• 18Cory ReddingDE · TexasTaken #66 by Detroit Lions69−21
• 19Jarret JohnsonDE · AlabamaTaken #109 by Baltimore Ravens63−27
• 20Dan KoppenPro Bowl ×1C · Boston Col.Taken #164 by New England Patriots63−27
• 21Osi UmenyioraAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×2DE · TroyTaken #56 by New York Giants62−28
• 22Ike TaylorDB · LouisianaTaken #125 by Pittsburgh Steelers62−28
• 23Nick BarnettLB · Oregon St.Taken #29 by Green Bay Packers60−30
• 24Nate BurlesonWR · NevadaTaken #71 by Minnesota Vikings59−31
• 25Marcus TrufantPro Bowl ×1DB · Washington St.Taken #11 by Seattle Seahawks58−32
• 26Willis McGaheePro Bowl ×2RB · Miami (FL)Taken #23 by Buffalo Bills57−33
• 27Bradie JamesLB · LSUTaken #103 by Dallas Cowboys56−34
• 28Chris KelsayDE · NebraskaTaken #48 by Buffalo Bills55−35
• 29Jeff FaineC · Notre DameTaken #21 by Cleveland Browns53−37
• 30Eric SteinbachG · IowaAlready on your team53−37
• 31Yeremiah BellPro Bowl ×1DB · Eastern KentuckyTaken #213 by Miami Dolphins53−37
• 32E.J. HendersonPro Bowl ×1LB · MarylandTaken #40 by Minnesota Vikings52−38
• 33Terrence McGeePro Bowl ×1DB · Northwestern St. (LA)Taken #111 by Buffalo Bills51−39
• 34Chris CrockerDB · MarshallTaken #84 by Cleveland Browns50−40
• 35Derrick DockeryG · TexasTaken #81 by Washington Redskins49−41
• 36Aubrayo FranklinDT · TennesseeTaken #146 by Baltimore Ravens49−41
• 37Wade SmithPro Bowl ×1T · MemphisTaken #78 by Miami Dolphins48−42
• 38Brandon LloydPro Bowl ×1WR · IllinoisTaken #124 by San Francisco 49ers48−42
• 39Scott ShanleLB · NebraskaTaken #251 by St. Louis Rams48−42
• 40Drayton FlorenceDB · TuskegeeTaken #46 by San Diego Chargers46−44
• 41Vince ManuwaiG · HawaiiTaken #72 by Jacksonville Jaguars46−44
• 42Larry JohnsonAll-Pro ×1Pro Bowl ×2RB · Penn St.Taken #27 by Kansas City Chiefs45−45
• 43Ken HamlinPro Bowl ×1DB · ArkansasTaken #42 by Seattle Seahawks45−45
• 44Pisa TinoisamoaLB · HawaiiTaken #43 by St. Louis Rams45−45
• 45Kevin WalterWR · Eastern MichiganTaken #255 by New York Giants45−45
• 46Tyler BraytonDE · ColoradoTaken #32 by Oakland Raiders44−46
• 47Reggie Wellscurrent swapG · ClarionTaken #177 by Arizona Cardinals42−48
• 48Ty WarrenDE · Texas A&MTaken #13 by New England Patriots41−49
• 49Eugene WilsonDB · IllinoisTaken #36 by New England Patriots40−50
• 50Kawika MitchellLB · South FloridaTaken #47 by Kansas City Chiefs40−50